Blind Spot 03: Letter From An Unknown Woman, 1948

this post is part of the blind spot series

Letter From
an Unknown Woman, 1948

directed by Max Ophüls
starring Joan Fontaine and Louis Jourdan

Yet again, Blind Spots elude me. I thought I was sitting down for a nice romance (again), and what came out of this viewing was something far different (again!). Lisa (Joan Fontaine) is a quiet woman. The type of shy, vulnerable, seemingly weak character we see Joan Fontaine often portray so brilliantly we just want to slap them in the face. She’s pining over Stefan (Louis Jourdan), a genius pianist and a ladies man who barely notices her.

That is until, of course, one day he does. And so our Lisa falls even harder. They go out, she comes up to his apartment – next thing you know, she’s pregnant. Except unlike in Love With The Proper Stranger (1963), abortion is not on the table. Funny how in this regard, 15 years in a movie seems centuries apart.

Spoilers Ahead!
If only you could’ve recognised what was always yours, could’ve found what was never lost.
— Joan Fontaine as Lisa

Before Lisa is aware of her condition, Stefan leaves on a train to somewhere (Italy?) for two weeks that eventually become a lifetime. Unsurprisingly, he forgot all about her. She keeps the child and raises it with another husband, who is fully aware of who the father is. Years later, Lisa and Stefan cross paths again. She is still in love. And we still want to slap her.

He, in turn, is pretty much ruined – both professionally and on a personal level. He turns to her and says the very same line that did her the first time around, and apparently still works: You could help me. Queue the eye-rolls of 21st century women. He wants everything, but gives her nothing.

It’s Safe Again
Letter From An Unknown Woman Joan Fontaine GIFLetter From An Unknown Woman Joan Fontaine GIF

Usually I can deal with the female condition in Old Hollywood movies, but in this case it was a bit too much for me. And in truth it wasn’t really Lisa, but rather Stefan. He did nothing to deserve her, and his wooing was all too transparent. He felt wrong from the start and so all I could do was cringe and try not to shout at a fictional character.

I know, I know: but Lisa was a young woman in love, blinded by her selfless (foolish) adoration for an asshole. I understand that. And I could write, objectively, about how good Letter From an Unknown Woman (1948) is. How it spins on itself and has a real perspective and arch for Lisa. How it even subverts the genre – especially considering its ending (which I do admire, for Lisa’s part).

And yet. She was so meek. And he was such an asshole.

Have you seen this movie? How was your own Blind Spot this month?
Don’t forget to leave your links below!

2

6 Comments

  1. April 17, 2018 / 1:21 PM

    You’re right, Joan Fontaine usually always played the same type of role: shy, meek, and very weak emotionally.

    • April 17, 2018 / 2:09 PM

      Right?! Usually I can deal with that, I really like Fontaine. But this time… her character being that way, and Stefan being such a player and unattractive because of that…. there was very little for me to hold on to. 😕

  2. April 17, 2018 / 2:52 PM

    I haven’t seen this one myself. I’ve got Singin’ In The Rain lined up for my April Blind spot.

    • April 19, 2018 / 10:42 AM

      Ooh I loved Singin’ In The Rain! I can’t remember much about it though, so it will be great to read your thoughts on it 😊

  3. April 18, 2018 / 11:48 AM

    Never heard about this one but it sounds like something that would agitate me as well :/

    • April 19, 2018 / 10:51 AM

      Yeah, in that case I would not recommend 😅 She really was SO blind

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *